Accept no Imitations: Senator Lee Outlines the Necessary Requirements of an Effective Balanced Budget Amendment

December 8, 2011

Accept no Imitations: Senator Lee Outlines the Necessary Requirements of an Effective Balanced Budget Amendment

Senator Lee: Mr. President, I stand today to urge my colleagues to support efforts to bring forward a balanced budget amendment, one that can be passed out of both houses of Congress and submitted to the states for ratification.

Article 5 of the Constitution gives us the power to change the Constitution from time to time, to modify our law of laws, that 224-year-old document that has fostered the development of the greatest civilization the world has ever known. We have done this 27 times. We have done it at times when in order to protect and preserve the nation that our ancestors fought so valiantly to create and later again to defend. We have to modify our government, the manner in which we do business in order to preserve that system, in order to make it strong, in order to ensure that it will continue to be strong for future generations.

We made it stronger when, for example, we added the Bill of Rights shortly after the ratification of the Constitution. We made it stronger again when, for example, we added the so-called civil war amendments, the 13th, 14th, and 15th amendments, ending slavery and the incidents thereof.  We made it stronger when we made it clear that women must always be given the right to vote. We made it stronger a number of times.

The time to make it stronger has come yet again. It’s time to modify the Constitution to limit, to restrict Congress’ current power granted by article 1, section 8, clause 2 of the Constitution, to borrow money on credit of the United States.

The reason we need to do this is because this power has been so severely abused over such a prolonged period of time that it’s causing devastating consequences for our economy and for our ability to fund the operations of government. We have now accumulated over $15 trillion in debt as a country. That works out to about $50,000 for every man, woman and child in America. It works out, arguably, to about $120,000 to $150,000 for every taxpayer in America. This is a lot of money.

It also represents about 90%, between 90% and 100% of our gross domestic product annually depending on whose statistics you follow. This is troubling given that once a country’s debt to GDP ratio crosses the significant 90% threshold — which we have now done — economic growth tends to slow, tends to slow to a point that an economy as large as ours can expect to lose as many as a million jobs a year. We can’t afford to lose jobs, especially when we know what one of the major causes is, our national debt.

It’s time that we change the way we do business. It’s time to change the manner in which Congress acquires new debt. This is no longer an issue that is either Republican or democratic, that’s either liberal or conservative. It is simply American.

I remind my colleagues that whether you’re most concerned on the one hand about preserving America’s leading edge, its ability to fund its national defense program, or on the other hand if you’re most concerned about funding entitlement programs, you should want a balanced budget amendment because this is what we need to do, this is what we have to do in order to protect our ability to fund both of those things, and everything else that we do.

You see, because by the end of this decade, according to the White House’s own numbers, we will be paying close to a trillion dollars every year just to pay the interest on our national debt, just the interest alone. We’re currently spending a little over $200 billion a year on interest. Still,  a lot of money, but about $800 billion lower than what we’re likely to be spending by the end of this decade. Where will that additional $800 billion every single year come from? This isn’t a discretionary sum. This is money that we have to pay. It’s the first thing that we have to pay. Where will that $800 billion difference be made up? At that point, we can’t expect simply to raise taxes to make up that difference. I’m not aware of any tax increase plan that could bring in that much additional revenue every year without stagnating our economy to the point that we might within a year or two bring in less revenue rather than more, certainly not $800 billion more. Nor am I aware of any plan whereby we could simply borrow an additional $800 billion just to pay that interest, because doing so, of course, would cause our interest rates to skyrocket, grow out of control, and our interest payments would be even more significant at that point, thus further impairing our ability to fund everything from defense to entitlements.

So at that point, the only option on the table would be dramatic, severe, abrupt, even draconian cuts to everything from defense to entitlements and everything in between. We don’t want this, there is a better way, and the better way forward that consists of a permanent structural spending reform that can be achieved only through a balanced budget amendment.

Now, let me explain what I mean by that. More importantly, let me explain what I don’t mean by that. We have to beware of things that masquerade as balanced budget amendments, things that will actually do the job instead of purporting to do the job, distracting the public’s attention away from the need to do this, while in effect doing nothing.

We need to be aware of what I sometimes call the Trojan horse balanced budget amendment proposal.

So there are a few hallmarks of what a real effective balanced budget amendment would accomplish. First and foremost, it has to apply to all spending in requiring Congress to provide a supermajority vote for any borrowing authority. There are some that have suggested that we should have a balanced budget amendment that exempts certain categories of entitlement spending, but of course as we all know, it’s entitlement spending that it continues to consume a larger and larger share of our national budget each and every year. It’s entitlement spending that is anticipated to have shortfalls for sums that will have to be expended for people, Americans alive today, could range anywhere from $50 trillion to $60 trillion to $110 trillion in unfunded entitlement liabilities.

So simply exempting out entire categories of entitlements is one of these hallmarks of a Trojan horse balanced budget amendment. We can’t do that. We need it to apply to all federal outlays, all federal spending.

Second, an effective balanced budget amendment must cap spending at the average historical level of federal revenue. Over the last 40 years, our average take, our average income as a percentage of GDP has been about,  18% to 18.5% of our gross domestic product. So we need to make sure that we’re not spending more than that, that Congress can’t without a supermajority vote spend more than 18% of GDP in any given year. Otherwise, we run the risk that Congress will find a way through tricky accounting schemes to circumvent the restrictions to make sure that it’s not spending more than it  takes in.

Third, the supermajority requirement must apply to the votes in both houses of Congress every single time Congress wants to spend more than it takes in. Any balanced budget amendment proposal that allows for a simple majority to bring about an exception to these spending limitations is one that Congress can and will use to circumvent the amendment entirely.

Let me explain what I mean. We have had in the past certain statutory legislative limitations on Congress’ spending and borrowing power. Some of these have been known as the Graham-Rudman-Hollings legislation. Also the PAYGO rules. But because Congress makes those laws and because they haven’t been reduced to a Constitutional amendment, just as Congress giveth, Congress taketh away and it sees fit to exempt itself out of those rules.

A balanced budget amendment even while enshrined in our Constitution becomes no more effective than those statutory or internal rules unless every time Congress wants to get around those limitations, it is required to cast a supermajority vote to justify that excess.

Finally, an effective balanced budget amendment must require that Congress cast a supermajority vote any time we raise the debt limit. This will give us an additional guarantee that tricky accounting mechanisms won’t be used to circumvent some of these most important restrictions.

Without these restrictions, Mr. President, Congress will continue to spend out of control because members of Congress tend to be rewarded when they spend and they tend to be criticized when they cut, and political pressures are such that I fear this spending will continue out of control in perpetuity until that moment when we reach our natural mathematical borrowing limit, not our statutory limit, our mathematical limit.

It’s at that point, Mr. President, when the most abrupt, painful, draconian cuts will have to be made. We can do this in a way that’s sensitive to the needs of the most vulnerable Americans, those who have become the most dependent upon our entitlement state, those that have become dependent for their day-to-day existence on these very programs. Those programs will have to be cut abruptly in a most painful manner unless we take the necessary steps right now and start moving on to a smooth glide path towards a balanced budget amendment.

…

So the American people are paying for Washington’s fiscal irresponsibility in the form of job losses, in the form of increased prices for goods and for services, and in the form of inflation.

It’s likewise my experience with my state legislature, that they seem to be very supportive of it. In fact, I have a document here signed by the legislative leaders of my state, by Governor Gary Herbert, by Utah House of Representatives Speaker Rebecca Lockhart and by Utah State Senate President Michael Waddups. They say — quote — “we urge the United States Senate and House of Representatives to pass a balanced budget amendment and send it to the states for ratification. Additionally, we urge Congress to make Utah’s concurrent resolution part of the Congressional Record.”

They also proceed to explain why they feel so strongly about this. They say not only for our own sake but for future generations as well, the states must now combine in an unwavering resolve with convincing action to put the nation’s financial house in order.

Passage of your own state’s resolution urging the support for a balanced budget amendment can help make this happen. Please join with Utah and call upon Congress immediately to pass a balanced budget amendment. We respectfully encourage you and urge your Congressional delegation to act in your behalf. They’re calling not only on Congress but also on their fellow state legislators throughout the country to urge this same action from Congress. And in the same breath they also adopted and they supported whole heartedly the specific balanced budget amendment found in Senate joint resolution 10.

I thank them for doing that and I think they reflect views of so many of our state legislatures which balance their budgets every single year. Most of them do. It’s not news when they do it. It’s not news because it’s what’s expected. It’s what’s expected because that’s what they do. I look forward to the day and age when it’s no longer news, when Congress balances its budget.

…

Perhaps it is inherent in the institution itself, in the forces at play, that have made Congress uniquely vulnerable to this kind of massive deficit spending. But whatever the reason, we know that Congress isn’t willing, isn’t able or at least in recent years has not been inclined except in rare, unusual circumstances to balance its own budget.

That being the case, we can’t assume that Congress will all of a sudden start doing its job as those who have used this argument have insisted. Part of Congress’ job as Congress has come to perceive it is to engage in deficit spending.

One of Congress’ powers as members of Congress who read the Constitution will point out, is to borrow money on credit of the United States. And so it isn’t enough simply to say Congress, do your job, because it has regarded this kind of massive deficit as consistent with that mandate, consistent with that injunction. Meanwhile, Congress continues to occupy a larger and larger share of the American economy.

We have to remember that for the first 150 years or so of our Republic’s existence, at the federal level we were spending between 1% and 4% of gross domestic product at the federal, national level with only two brief exception, once during the civil war and one in the immediate aftermath of World War I. But that all started to change in the 1930’s when we broke into double digits for the first time ever during peace time. We’ve never really gone back, and now the federal government is spending about 25% of GDP annually — GDP annually. Roughly a quarter of every dollar that moves through the American economy every year is taken out of the real economy by Washington. It’s absorbed within the federal morass that is our government. That’s a problem. That needs to change.

I fear, I suspect, I firmly believe that it will not change until we take this power away, until we at least impose severe restrictions on Congress’ borrowing power because it has become part of Congress’ nature to engage in this kind of out-of-control deficit spending.

 …

And I think it’s important for us to remind our colleagues that because the American people overwhelmingly support this, by a margin of about 75%, according to a recent CNN poll, those who oppose it, those who are members of this body or of our sister body, the US House of representatives just down the hall, who choose not to support it will do so, will cast their “no” vote at their own political peril. Because the American people are standing up and they are demanding more.

They understand that in the words of Benjamin Franklin, “he’ll cheat without scruple who can without fear.”

When Congress is free to spend more than it takes in every single year without political consequence, bad things happen. Congress starts to manipulate more and more of the economy and that is something that the American people understand is hurtful rather than helpful to them, to the people on the ground, to the person who’s unemployed and looking for a job, for the person who’s underemployed or underpaid for the work that he does. Or the single mother who’s just worried about taking care of their children. For the grandparents who are worried about the future of their grandchildren, worried about the fact that for the first time in American history, Americans fear that they will enjoy a lower standard of living than what they have enjoyed.

All of this is due to the fact that Congress has known no real boundaries to its authority and recognized no real limits on its ability to spend your hard-earned money. This has real consequences.

But we can forestall those negative consequences right now if we will act to restrict on a permanent and structural basis Congress’s ability to engage in deficit spending.

Accept no imitations. Beware of the Trojan horse balanced budget amendment, the one that can be circumvented easy by a simple majority vote. Beware of the balanced budget amendment that doesn’t limit as a percentage of GDP Congress’s ability to spend money. Look out for these principles.

We get this balanced budget amendment passed, submit it to the states for ratification, they will ratify it and we will find that our best days as Americans are yet ahead of us. I urge my colleagues to cast a vote in favor of senate joint resolution 10. Thank you, mr. President.

Print 
Email 
Share 
Share