If you’re creating a budget, what’s the first thing you need to know: How much you have or how much you want to spend?
The answer to this question exposes a fundamental difference between how Republicans and Democrats approach the nation’s finances. And it was on full display last week in the Senate.
Republicans have united together behind S.J.Res. 10, the Hatch-Lee Balanced Budget Amendment which forces Congress to balance its budget each year, limits spending to 18% of GDP, and requires a supermajority to raise taxes or increase the debt ceiling.
Why did we choose to limit spending at 18%? Because it is the 40-year average of annual federal tax receipts. In other words, through taxation, the U.S. collects roughly 18% of GDP in any given year. That’s how much we usually have, so in order to balance the budget, that’s how much we should be allowed to spend.
That’s called fiscal responsibility and conscientious budgeting.
Last week, however, a Senate colleague attempting to criticize the GOP’s effort to pass a balanced budget amendment to the Constitution asked why we would limit spending to 18% of GDP and answered his own question this way:
They said they want to limit government spending to 18% of GDP. I’d like to ask: where does that number come from? Why is it 18%? Why isn’t it 18.5%? Why isn’t it 17.75%? Why isn’t 19.23%? Where does 18% come from? Madam President, let me tell you where this comes from. The last time that the federal government was 18% of GDP spending was 1967, before Medicare really got underway. So read between the lines. What the Republicans are saying, if they could get that down to 18%, we could do away with Medicare, which is what they want to do anyway.
In this statement the Senator is not referring to what the federal government collects in federal taxes, but rather how much the U.S. actually spends. So technically, he’s right: “The last time that the federal government was 18% of GDP spending was 1967”. In other words, since 1967, Congress has continually outspent what it collects in taxes. Which is exactly why we have accumulated so much debt in the last few decades and now face a debt crisis. If you want to reduce or eliminate your deficit, you only budget for and spend what you have. You don’t spend whatever you want and hope revenue keeps up. The Democrats have it exactly backwards.
In addition, the BBA says nothing about how the federal government should spend what it collects. It can be entitlements, education, national defense or whatever