The AT&T/T-Mobile Merger: Is Humpty Dumpty Being Put Back Together Again?

May 11, 2011

The AT&T/T-Mobile Merger: Is Humpty Dumpty Being Put Back Together Again?

Ranking Member Statement:

Given the
large number of witnesses participating in this hearing as well as the
complexity of the issues before us, I will keep my opening remarks brief in
order to allow more time for questions and answers.

The
mobile phone market is a critical component of our nation’s economy.  According to recent estimates, it is directly
responsible for more than 250,000 jobs, generates over $150 billion of economic
activity each year, and accounts for nearly $25 billion in annual capital
investment.

It is
difficult to overstate the increasing importance of mobile devices in the lives
of virtually all Americans.  Many people
rely on wireless phones as their principal means of communications, with more
than a quarter of the population having become wireless-only households.  Mobile devices are also increasingly a
primary means by which individuals access the Internet.  Next year smartphone sales are expected to be
greater than the combined sales of both desktop and laptop computers.

This
explosion in demand for wireless services has led to significant capacity
constraints throughout the industry.   Most of us are all too familiar with dropped
calls and sluggish data speeds.  The
strength of available wireless networks is vital to individuals, families,
schools, businesses, public safety organizations, and virtually all aspects of
modern communications.  With the current
capacity crunch in mind, the Obama administration announced last year in the
National Broadband Plan a goal to “lead the world in mobile innovation, with
the fastest and most extensive wireless networks of any nation.”

An
important question before our Subcommittee today is whether the proposed merger
between AT&T and T-Mobile is a positive step along the path to world-class wireless
broadband throughout the United States. 

There are
a number of reasons to believe that the merger could contribute to this
goal.  In many respects, AT&T and
T-Mobile are unique in having roughly compatible networks, complementary
spectrum holdings, and well-matched cell-site grids.  A merger between the two companies may
provide significant and immediate efficiencies that will enable enhanced
service quality, fewer blocked or dropped calls, and increasing data speeds.

Ultimately,
the entire wireless industry will require additional spectrum to address the significant
growth in demand for mobile broadband services. 
Until such spectrum is made available, the benefits of this proposed
merger will enable AT&T to roll out its 4G LTE network.  And AT&T has committed to provide this
more advanced wireless broadband service to 97 percent of the U.S.
population.  In addition to offering better
services and speeds, 4G nationwide networks create opportunities for handset
innovation and the development of data-rich applications.

I favor
market approaches, rather than government funding and intervention, to develop
nationwide mobile broadband networks. The U.S. wireless marketplace is in many
ways less concentrated than in other industrialized nations.  Some suggest that our national interest would
be disserved by restricting the American marketplace to a larger number of
spectrum-starved providers ill-equipped to build the most advanced wireless
networks. 

At the
same time, I share some of the concerns expressed by my colleague, Senator
Kohl, and believe it is our responsibility—along with the Department of
Justice’s Antitrust Division and the Federal Communications Commission—to
ensure that the proposed merger would not produce damaging anticompetitive
effects.

The
combination of AT&T and T-Mobile would create the largest wireless carrier
in the nation, with roughly 42 percent of all wireless subscribers in the
United States.  And it would leave the
market with only three (rather than four) nationwide carriers that account for
the vast majority of total subscribers.

A
critical question, therefore, is whether the smaller regional carriers can
effectively compete in a post-merger market, helping to discipline prices,
preserve consumer choice, and promote innovation.  Two potential roadblocks to robust
competition deserve special attention. 

First,
regional carriers with limited spectrum holdings must rely on the large
national carriers for data roaming access outside their local areas.  Although a recent FCC order mandates that
major carriers offer “commercially reasonable” data roaming agreements, the
terms and conditions of these agreements will largely determine whether smaller
carriers can become a true competitive force in a nationwide market.

Second,
regional providers are often at a competitive disadvantage in gaining access to
the most popular and desirable handsets. 
National providers with large volume and advertising budget are better
positioned to negotiate exclusive contracts for cutting edge devices like the
iPhone and lower prices for other handsets purchased in bulk.

In
seeking to address these and other issues relating to the competitive position
of smaller regional carries, we would do well to remember the insight made
famous by Robert Bork’s seminal work The
Antitrust Paradox
: “Competition must be understood as the maximization of
consumer welfare.”  Our analysis of the
proposed merger between AT&T and T-Mobile should be guided by what will be
best for consumers—in the form of prices, service quality, and range of choice.

Print 
Email 
Share 
Share